Fact-checkers say deleted Jos rally crowd photo was AI-created — but the proof is not conclusive
Photo: Atiku Abubakar speaking at an ADC Congress event · Photo: Vanguard (published 16 November 2026) — not the Potiskum rally crowd and not the disputed Jos photo
A Nigerian fact-checking newsroom ran the deleted Jos rally photo through AI detectors and says AI was involved. Detection tools are not proof — and the Presidency still hasn't responded.
Key points
- FIJ ran the photo through detection tools on Monday.
- The photo was posted, questioned, then deleted.
- The Presidency has not responded.
Former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar, the ADC presidential candidate, has accused the Tinubu Presidency of using AI to fabricate rally crowds. In a statement issued on Monday by his Director of Strategic Communication, Phrank Shaibu, Atiku thanked the people of Potiskum, Yobe State, for the reception at his ADC campaign rally, then took aim at the Presidency over a photograph of the APC North-Central rally in Jos on Saturday, 14 November: “The Presidency may need artificial intelligence to conjure a crowd, but in Potiskum the people came out in flesh and blood, unfiltered, unedited and impossible to fabricate.”
He added: “The Presidency's AI must have forgotten that crowds need seats and that people do not fly. Perhaps in Tinubu's imaginary rally, the supporters were expected to hover through the speech.”
The photograph in question was posted on X on Sunday by Tinubu's media aide, Dada Olusegun, captioned “Plateau State for PBAT”, and was deleted after social-media users compared it with photos and videos from the event showing sections of the venue with fewer people and accused the aide of using AI to exaggerate the turnout. Atiku also commended the Yobe governor for a level playing field and referred to chants of “Tinubu Must Go” at ADC rallies.
The genuine new development: the Foundation for Investigative Journalism (FIJ), a Nigerian non-profit newsroom, reported on Monday that it ran the disputed photograph through detection tools and concluded that artificial intelligence was involved in creating or altering it. The Atlantic Digest, which also covered the story on Monday, notes it has not examined the original file.
CAUTION, and it matters: detection tools give probabilistic results and are not conclusive on their own — the strongest evidence is a comparison with verified footage from the event, which FIJ's report does not yet supply in full. The AI conclusion is FIJ's, based on detection tools — it must be presented as such. What IS established: the photo was posted, users questioned it, it was deleted, and a Nigerian fact-checking newsroom now says its tools indicate AI involvement. The claim that the image was AI-generated is STRONGER than yesterday but still NOT established as fact. Atiku's Monday statement — “The Presidency's AI must have forgotten that crowds need seats and that people do not fly” — still stands as an allegation, and the Presidency still has not responded.
Update, 17 Nov 2026 (morning): the Foundation for Investigative Journalism reported on Monday that its detection tools indicate AI was involved in creating or altering the deleted Jos rally crowd photo. The finding is a detection-tool indication, not forensic proof — and the image is still not presented here as proven AI-generated.
Why this matters
Fact-checkers ran the deleted Jos rally photo through AI detectors — and they say AI was involved. Detection tools are not proof.
Latest developments
First published 16 Nov 2026, 19:26 WAT.
Updated 17 Nov 2026, 08:12 WAT — this report was updated after publication.
Related coverage on NewsFlux:
- “We’re hungry” — Plateau residents burn Tinubu’s caps and brooms after the Jos rally, as Baba-Ahmed warns Nigeria is in trouble · 14 Nov 2026, 19:27 WAT
- South Africa demarches Fani-Kayode over his livestream complaint — and reminds him of the Vienna Convention · 17 Nov 2026, 19:43 WAT
- One killed, six injured as Gombe APC chairman’s convoy crashes on the way to a campaign rally · 17 Nov 2026, 19:43 WAT
Sources
- Atlantic Digest — Presidential aide deletes Jos rally crowd photo after AI manipulation claims (16 Nov 2026)
- Foundation for Investigative Journalism — FIJ fact-check on the deleted Jos rally photo (16 Nov 2026, via Atlantic Digest)
- ThisDay — 2027: I don't need AI to conjure campaign crowd, Atiku mocks Tinubu (16 Nov 2026)
- Vanguard — Atiku thanks Yobe people for warm campaign reception (16 Nov 2026)
- Legit.ng — 2027 election: Atiku accuses Tinubu Presidency of using AI to fabricate rally crowds (16 Nov 2026)
- Papers.com.ng — Our crowd is real: Atiku mocks Tinubu over AI-generated Jos rally photo (16 Nov 2026)
FIJ's detection tools indicate AI involvement in the deleted Jos rally photo — a probabilistic indication, not forensic proof. The image is not presented here as proven AI-generated. The Presidency has not responded.